Slips and mistakes
Two kinds of human error. In a slip the intention is right but the action goes wrong. In a mistake the action goes as planned, but the plan was wrong.
What problem it addresses
It explains why asking for “more care” is not enough. It teaches design that each kind of error is prevented differently: slips, with clearly distinct actions; mistakes, with better information.
An example
Two errors at home that look alike but aren’t.
The first is prevented by separating and distinguishing the knobs. The second, by showing how the device works.
Why it happens
Acting has two parts: deciding what to do and doing it.
If the doing fails, it’s a slip, especially in tasks we do without thinking.
If the deciding fails, it’s a mistake, even if every step is done right.
Applications in design
Use it like this
Against slips, make similar actions distinct and allow undo. Against mistakes, show the system’s state and what is about to happen.
Avoid
Blaming the person using it and solving everything with an “Are you sure?” warning.
Don’t fall for it
If many people make the same slip, the problem lies in the design, not in their attention.
About 1,000 slips
What the research says
Everyday errors that Norman collected and classified by where the action goes wrong; about 200 were his own (Norman, 1981).
Solid evidence. It is not a representative sample, so it serves to sort types, not to measure how often each one happens. Reason (1990) added memory failures, which he called lapses.
Connections
Authors and works
- 1981
Donald A. Norman
Classified slips by the point where the action goes astray, from the intention to the movement.
- 1990
James Reason
Separated failures of execution (slips and lapses) from failures of planning (mistakes).
- 2013
Donald A. Norman
Brought the distinction to design and argued that a frequent error points to a design problem.
Sources
Original sources
- Norman, D. A. (1981). Categorization of action slips. Psychological Review, 88(1), 1–15. View source: Norman, D. A. (1981)
- Reason, J. (1990). Human error. Cambridge University Press. View source: Reason, J. (1990)
- Norman, D. A. (2013). The design of everyday things (Rev. and expanded ed.). Basic Books.
Last reviewed: