Skip to content
APDD
See my library

Concept

Privacy nutrition label

A fixed-format summary of a privacy policy, inspired by food nutrition facts, that shows at a glance what data is collected and what for.

In Spanish
Etiqueta de privacidad
Origin
Kelley, Bresee, Cranor and Reeder (2009), Carnegie Mellon University; inspired by the US Nutrition Facts panel

What problem it addresses

Almost nobody reads privacy policies: in an experiment, 74% skipped it when signing up for a social network (Obar and Oeldorf-Hirsch, 2018). Design takes from here a fixed format that can be read and compared in seconds.

An example

An illustrative example: you want to know whether an online store shares your email address with other companies.

Full policy
Several pages of text; the answer is one sentence, in the middle of a section. You give up halfway.
Label
A table with types of data in rows, uses in columns, and a mark where each applies. You find it in seconds.

Because the format is always the same, it also lets you compare two services without reading two long documents.

Why it happens

  1. Reading every policy takes too long, so we accept without reading.

  2. The label arranges the same content in a short table that always has the same shape.

  3. It is quick to search and compare, and you finally know what you are saying yes to.

Applications in design

  • Use it like this

    Summarize your policy in a fixed format, with the same rows and columns across all your products, and test it with real people.

  • Avoid

    A label that leaves out the uncomfortable parts: if it summarizes, it has to summarize everything, including what is shared with third parties.

  • Don’t fall for it

    Having a summary doesn’t give you permission to hide what matters in the long policy.

6.83 → 10.13

TextLabel

What the research says

Average correct answers from 24 people who looked up information in a privacy policy as text and as a label; with the label they took less than half the time (Kelley et al., 2009).

Single study. It is a small lab study. An online study with 764 people confirmed that fixed formats work better than text and than layered notices (Kelley et al., 2010).

Authors and works

  1. 2009

    Patrick Gage Kelley, Joanna Bresee, Lorrie Faith Cranor and Robert Reeder

    Designed the label through several prototypes and focus groups, and compared it with text policies.

  2. 2010

    Patrick Gage Kelley, Lucian Cesca, Joanna Bresee and Lorrie Faith Cranor

    Showed with hundreds of people that a fixed format works better than the full text and than layered notices.

  3. 2018

    Jonathan Obar and Anne Oeldorf-Hirsch

    Measured that almost nobody reads the policies when signing up, and that 98% missed absurd clauses hidden in the terms of service.

Sources

Original sources

Last reviewed: