Design hierarchy of needs
A family of pyramids, inspired by Maslow's, that order what is expected of a design, from working to being pleasant or creative, and ask you to settle each level before the next.
What problem it addresses
Helps decide what to fix first, but it is an analogy for prioritizing, not a proven theory: the levels are their authors' proposals.
An example
An illustrative example: two versions of the same app.
Delightful details are worth little if what comes before fails.
How it works
Start from Maslow: needs at the bottom are met before those above.
Each author proposes levels for a design, from what works to what delights.
Move up a level once the one below is settled.
Applications in design
Use it like this
To decide the order of work: first make it work and be reliable, then usable, and then what delights.
Avoid
Treating the levels as a law; no studies show they must be met in that order.
Don’t fall for it
Waiting for one level to be perfect before starting the next: a pleasant detail can be tested early.
4, 5 and 6
What the research says
These are the numbers of levels in the pyramids compared. Walter (2011) uses four, Lidwell, Holden and Butler (2003) and Bradley (2010) five, and Anderson, according to van Gemert (2018), six.
Debated evidence. That each author uses a different number shows the levels don't come from data. Van Gemert (2018) also finds no direct correspondence with Maslow, and Maslow's hierarchy has weak empirical support (Wahba and Bridwell, 1976).
Connections
Used in
Authors and works
- 2003
William Lidwell, Kritina Holden and Jill Butler
Included in their book a five-level hierarchy, from functionality to creativity.
- 2010
Steven Bradley
Adapted Maslow's hierarchy to web design with five levels and presented it as a guide, not a strict rule.
- 2011
Aarron Walter
Proposed a four-level pyramid (functional, reliable, usable and pleasurable) for designing with emotion.
- 2017
Therese Fessenden
Built on Walter's pyramid to tell surface delight, a pleasant detail, from deep delight, which only comes once the basics work.
- 2018
Vasilis van Gemert
Compared the pyramids of Maslow, Walter and Anderson, and found no direct correspondence with Maslow.
Sources
Original sources
- Lidwell, W., Holden, K., & Butler, J. (2003). Universal principles of design. Rockport Publishers.
- Bradley, S. (2010, April 26). Designing for a hierarchy of needs. Smashing Magazine. View source: Bradley, S. (2010, April 26)
- Walter, A. (2011). Designing for emotion. A Book Apart.
Academic reviews
- Wahba, M. A., & Bridwell, L. G. (1976). Maslow reconsidered: A review of research on the need hierarchy theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance. View source: Wahba, M. A., & Bridwell, L. G. (1976)
Secondary sources
- Fessenden, T. (2017, March 5). A theory of user delight: Why usability is the foundation for delightful experiences. Nielsen Norman Group. View source: Fessenden, T. (2017, March 5)
- van Gemert, V. (2018, February 8). A comparison of three pyramids. vasilis.nl. View source: van Gemert, V. (2018, February 8)
Last reviewed: